ad-bidding-strategy — Paid, an agent skill published by mbfinotti/advertising-skills

Paid

mbfinotti/advertising-skillsskills.sh ↗

Installs

26,440

deduplicated, at the last sync

Since we started

+483.9%

25 readings, about 2 days apart. Not a live curve.

Our category

Paid

ours

Last read

Nov 22, 2026

from the directory

Our brief

ours

This skill acts as a paid-media bidding strategist that interviews the user about their campaign goals, conversion tracking, margins, and risk tolerance, then recommends and drafts a bidding policy document. It classifies bid strategies into structural archetypes across platforms, derives targets from both economics and historical performance, and defines change discipline with evaluation windows and rollback triggers. It does not execute platform changes; it only produces the policy for the user to implement.

What it produces
  • bidding policy document
  • archetype recommendation
  • target derivation worksheet
  • evaluation window schedule
  • rollback trigger definition
What it needs
  • interview answers on goals and metrics
  • historical conversion performance data
  • margin or deal economics data
  • platform and campaign details
  • risk tolerance and deadline info
Paid services

not detected

The evidence describes advertising bidding costs and economics, but contains no indication that the skill itself requires a paid plan, API key, or credential.

Registration

not detected

The skill is MIT-licensed and runs as an agent skill; the evidence does not mention any registration or account requirement for using it.

Limits and human review

The skill cannot execute bid changes on ad platforms, allocate budgets across campaigns, pace spend against budgets, or repair broken conversion tracking. It also cannot fix unit-economics problems where break-even targets sit below historically achieved performance. It routes those issues to separate skills or business decisions.

Evidencestatic findingsskills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/strategy-archetypes.md:1-29skills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/target-derivation.md:1-51skills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/worked-examples.md:1-39+1
static findingsstatic_finding
[{"code":"payment","match":"per month","path":"SKILL.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"pricing","path":"SKILL.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"pricing","path":"references/target-derivation.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"pricing","path":"references/worked-examples.md"}]
skills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/strategy-archetypes.md1–29 · excerpt truncated
# Strategy Archetypes

This file covers:

- the four structural axes
- the archetypes ranked by return per unit of effort, with the goal and evidence each one requires
- the documented eligibility thresholds (dated)
- the platform-label translation table

## The four axes

Every bid strategy on every platform is one combination of four choices:

| Axis                      | Options                                                                        | What it decides                                   |
| ------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------- |
| 1. Optimization objective | clicks/traffic · impressions/visibility · conversion volume · conversion value | What the algorithm is rewarded for                |
| 2. Constraint             | uncapped (maximize) · capped (target)                                          | Whether efficiency bounds the maximizer           |
| 3. Control type           | average-based goal · hard per-auction ceiling                                  | Whether individual auctions may exceed the number |
| 4. Signal scope           | single-
skills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/target-derivation.md1–51 · excerpt truncated
# Target Derivation

This file covers:

- the two derivations every target needs, worked both ways
- the volume-threshold derivation
- the staleness/refresh discipline

Label every number you produce with its evidence tier: **documented**, **practitioner-convergent**, or **folklore**.

## Derivation 1 - from economics: the affordable ceiling

Core formulas (keep platform-attributed revenue, blended business revenue, and contribution margin distinct - never conflate):

```
break_even_CPA        = contribution per accepted conversion
break_even_ROAS       = 1 ÷ contribution_margin_rate
target_ROAS_with_profit_goal = 1 ÷ (contribution_margin_rate − desired_net_margin)
AOV form              : break_even_ROAS = AOV ÷ (AOV − variable costs per order)
                        variable costs = COGS + shipping + fees + returns allowance
```

Margin → break-even return:

| Margin | Break-even return |
| ------ | ----------------- |
| 50%    | 2.0x              |
| 40%    | 2.5x              |
| 33%    | 3.0x              |
| 25%    | 4.0x              |
| 10%    | 10.0x             |

The folk "aim for 4x" is exactly right for a 25%-margin business and wrong for everyone else.

B2C worked exa
skills/ad-bidding-strategy/references/worked-examples.md1–39 · excerpt truncated
# Worked Examples

Two complete bidding policies - one B2B, one B2C - and one negative example annotated line by line. Numbers are illustrative; every real policy derives its own.

## Table of Contents

- [Brainstorming example - B2B account, three candidates](#brainstorming-example-b2b-account-three-candidates)
- [Example 1 - B2B SaaS, search platform, lead generation](#example-1-b2b-saas-search-platform-lead-generation)
- [Example 2 - B2C e-commerce, paid social, revenue](#example-2-b2c-e-commerce-paid-social-revenue)
- [Negative example - what not to do](#negative-example-what-not-to-do)

## Brainstorming example - B2B account, three candidates

Example shape, for a B2B account with ~25 conversions/month and no offline imports - candidates listed in efficiency order, best ratio first:

- **(a) Cost-goal at trailing actual.**
  - Buys: cost control at the efficiency the account already achieves.
  - Costs: about an hour of derivation plus a standing review cadence; some volume; variance at this conversion count makes target diagnosis slow.
  - Must be true: the tracked event predicts revenue; the target sits at trailing actual, not the aspirational number.
- **(b) Volume-maximizi
skills/ad-bidding-strategy/SKILL.md1–135 · excerpt truncated
---
name: ad-bidding-strategy
description: "Choose the bidding policy per platform and goal - manual vs automated, cost-goal vs value/return-goal, when to switch, and how to set and move the target - written up as a policy with an evaluation window, change discipline, and a rollback trigger. Use whenever the user mentions a bid strategy, target CPA or target ROAS, smart or automated bidding, bid cap vs cost cap, portfolio bid strategies, seasonal bid adjustments, value-based bidding readiness, or delivery collapsing after a target change - even if they never say 'bidding'. Covers B2B and B2C. Do NOT use to split budgets across campaigns (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-allocation) or to track spend against a budget (mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-budget-pacing)."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: Maya-Beth Finotti
  version: "1.2.7"
---

# Bidding Strategy

You are a paid-media bidding strategist. Own the macro decision: which bidding approach to run per platform and goal, how to set and move its target, and when to switch. Recommend and draft policy; never execute platform changes.

Three ideas carry the whole exercise:

- **The bidder optimizes whatever the account labelled

Read 5 of 5 text files in the skill.

Checked November 2026 · nemotron-3-ultra-550b-a55b:freeWritten from the skill's published files. Check the source before relying on access or cost details.

Installfrom the directory

npx skills add https://github.com/mbfinotti/advertising-skills

Installing happens there, not here. We are an index with an opinion, not a mirror.

What is inside itfrom the directory

evals/evals.json
references/strategy-archetypes.md
references/target-derivation.md
references/worked-examples.md
SKILL.md

5 files — names only. The directory does not report sizes.

What the auditors foundfrom the directory

A skill is instructions your agent will follow and scripts it may run, so who checked it matters as much as how many people installed it.

Gen Agent Trust HubThe skill is a strategic framework for managing advertising bidding policies. It relies on a user interview process to generate recommendations. The analysis identified a potential for indirect prompt injection from user inputs or external documentation, which is a standard architectural risk for this type of skill. No executable code, secrets, or malicious patterns were found.Sep 13, 2026 · SAFEpass
SocketNo alertsSep 13, 2026pass
SnykRisk: LOW · No issuesSep 13, 2026 · LOWpass

Installs, reading by readingours

4.5k
26.4k
Oct 4, 202625 readings, about 2 days apart. Not a live curve.Nov 22, 2026

Axis starts at 4.5k, not zero — the range is 4.5k to 26.4k.

Asked out loudspoken, not typed

The same skill in the words people use speaking to an assistant rather than typing into a box. Each one carries the situation it came from, and each answer says only what the skill's own files support.

before starting a projectdo I need to pay for this skill or connect an ad account to use it?

The skill is MIT-licensed and runs as an agent skill; the evidence shows no paid tier, API key, or credential requirement for the skill itself. Payment references in the files refer to advertising budgets and bidding economics, not the skill's cost.

reviewing the skill descriptionwill this thing actually change my bids in Google Ads or Meta?

No. The skill explicitly states it recommends and drafts policy but never executes platform changes. You or your team implement the policy manually or via your usual tools.

auditing current setupwhat if my conversion tracking is messed up — can this still help?

The skill gates all value or return-goal recommendations on measurement validity. If the optimization event is a proxy or values are untrustworthy, it routes you to the conversion-tracking skill first and only revisits bidding after measurement is repaired.

choosing a bid strategyhow does it decide between target CPA, target ROAS, and maximize conversions?

It classifies every platform strategy into four structural axes (objective, constraint, control type, signal scope) and ranks archetypes by return per unit of effort. The interview answers — goal, volume, margin, risk tolerance, deadline — determine which archetype fits, not platform labels.

Filed alongside itours