cac-roas-benchmark — Paid, an agent skill published by mbfinotti/advertising-skills

Paid

mbfinotti/advertising-skillsskills.sh ↗

Installs

26,697

deduplicated, at the last sync

Since we started

+482.4%

25 readings, about 2 days apart. Not a live curve.

Our category

Paid

ours

Last read

Nov 22, 2026

from the directory

Our brief

ours

The skill computes a business's CAC and ROAS family metrics from real spend and outcome data, then judges whether the spend is healthy against three references: the business's own break‑even, its own trailing history, and provenance‑labelled external benchmarks. It returns a verdict of healthy, watch, unhealthy, or insufficient evidence and provides the metric values with variant, window, and source. It is used whenever someone asks about CAC being too high, ROAS being good, ad profitability, or mentions MER, blended CAC, payback period, or a spend health check.

What it produces
  • Verdict (healthy/watch/unhealthy/insufficient evidence)
  • CAC metric (value, variant, window, source)
  • ROAS metric (value, variant, window, source)
  • Evidence gate status
  • Definitions record
What it needs
  • Business financial data (spend, revenue, customers)
  • Contribution margin or gross margin
  • Prior periods of the same metric
  • Evaluation window covering conversion lag
  • Definition of new customer and spend lines
Paid services

not detected

The evidence contains no mention of a required paid service or account.

Registration

not detected

The evidence contains no mention of a required registration or account.

Limits and human review

It cannot set policy guardrails or target thresholds; that is handled by a separate skill. It also does not provide budget pacing, allocation recommendations, or diagnostic root causes. It relies on the user providing the required financial data and definitions.

Evidencestatic findingsskills/cac-roas-benchmark/references/benchmark-sources.md:1-22skills/cac-roas-benchmark/references/worked-examples.md:1-72skills/cac-roas-benchmark/SKILL.md:1-101
static findingsstatic_finding
[{"code":"payment","match":"billing","path":"SKILL.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"subscription","path":"SKILL.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"Paddle","path":"references/benchmark-sources.md"},{"code":"payment","match":"billing","path":"references/worked-examples.md"}]
skills/cac-roas-benchmark/references/benchmark-sources.md1–22 · excerpt truncated
# Published CAC/ROAS benchmarks - provenance, figures, folklore

Every CAC/ROAS benchmark in circulation is either a vendor's client sample or a self-reported survey. There is no neutral, audited, industry-wide CAC or ROAS benchmark, and no standards body defines what enters the CAC numerator. Quote provenance with the number or do not quote the number.

## The evidence contract

Before citing any external figure in a report, attach all four fields - publisher, year, sample, and the metric variant it measured - plus the publisher's commercial interest when it has one. A figure missing any of these is quoted as "unverified" or dropped.

## Publishers worth naming

Rows run best-first, ordered by what a citation from each tier is worth:

- value: platform-instrumented vendor data > large self-reported surveys > agency client analytics > consultancy and AI-generated summary pages
- effort: all == (roughly an hour of sourcing per figure, whichever tier) - only value separates them, so never settle for a lower tier to save time

Platform-instrumented data is measured rather than recalled, but every tier is skewed to that publisher's own customer base: more credible is not neutral. The b
skills/cac-roas-benchmark/references/worked-examples.md1–72 · excerpt truncated
# Report template and worked examples

All business figures below (spend, revenue, margins, customer counts) are **invented illustrations of the method** - never quote them as benchmarks. The only external numbers are the cited published figures, which carry their provenance.

## Table of Contents

- [Report template](#report-template)
- [Headline](#headline)
- [Definitions record](#definitions-record)
- [Metric table](#metric-table)
- [Comparison ladder](#comparison-ladder)
- [Verdict and evidence gate](#verdict-and-evidence-gate)
- [Folklore appendix (only if raised)](#folklore-appendix-only-if-raised)
- [Handoffs](#handoffs)
- [Example 1 - B2C ecommerce (home-goods DTC brand, "Maple & Loam")](#example-1-b2c-ecommerce-home-goods-dtc-brand-maple-loam)
- [Example 2 - B2B SaaS (workflow vendor, "Quorline")](#example-2-b2b-saas-workflow-vendor-quorline)

## Report template

```markdown
# Spend Health Check - {business}, {window}

## Headline

- {segment/channel}: **{healthy | watch | unhealthy | insufficient evidence}** - rests on rung {1/2/3 used}. {one line why}

## Definitions record

Model: {B2B/B2C} · Window: {dates, lag maturity} · Spend lines: {…} ·
New customer = {…}, renewal
skills/cac-roas-benchmark/SKILL.md1–101 · excerpt truncated
---
name: cac-roas-benchmark
description: "Compute a business's CAC and ROAS family metrics from real spend and outcome data, then judge whether the spend is healthy against three references - the business's own break-even, its own trailing history, and provenance-labelled external benchmarks - returning healthy, watch, unhealthy, or insufficient evidence. Use whenever the user asks whether their CAC is too high, whether a ROAS is good, what ROAS to aim for, whether ads are profitable, or mentions MER, blended CAC, payback period, or a spend health check - even if they never say 'benchmark'. Covers B2B/SaaS (cost per SQL, cost per closed-won, cohort lag) and B2C/ecommerce. Do NOT use to set those thresholds as policy - use mbfinotti/advertising-skills@ad-spend-guardrails instead."
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: Maya-Beth Finotti
  version: "1.4.2"
---

# CAC & ROAS Spend Health Check

You are a marketing unit-economics analyst. Your deliverable is a spend health verdict: the business's CAC and ROAS family metrics, each labeled with its variant, window, and data source, judged against three references in strict priority order.

The calculation is trivial - the defensibility lives 

Read 4 of 4 text files in the skill.

Checked November 2026 · north-mini-code:freeWritten from the skill's published files. Check the source before relying on access or cost details.

Installfrom the directory

npx skills add https://github.com/mbfinotti/advertising-skills

Installing happens there, not here. We are an index with an opinion, not a mirror.

What is inside itfrom the directory

evals/evals.json
references/benchmark-sources.md
references/worked-examples.md
SKILL.md

4 files — names only. The directory does not report sizes.

What the auditors foundfrom the directory

A skill is instructions your agent will follow and scripts it may run, so who checked it matters as much as how many people installed it.

Gen Agent Trust HubThe skill is a set of analytical instructions and reference data for marketing unit economics. It contains no executable code, network operations, or sensitive file access. All external references are to related skills by the same author.Sep 13, 2026 · SAFEpass
SocketNo alertsSep 13, 2026pass
SnykRisk: LOW · No issuesSep 13, 2026 · LOWpass

Installs, reading by readingours

4.6k
26.7k
Oct 4, 202625 readings, about 2 days apart. Not a live curve.Nov 22, 2026

Axis starts at 4.6k, not zero — the range is 4.6k to 26.7k.

Asked out loudspoken, not typed

The same skill in the words people use speaking to an assistant rather than typing into a box. Each one carries the situation it came from, and each answer says only what the skill's own files support.

when evaluating costDo I need to pay for this?

The skill does not require a paid service or account; it runs locally using your data.

when picking between two skillsWill this thing touch my repo?

The skill does not access or modify repositories; it only processes the financial data you provide.

before a standupDo I need to sign up or create an account?

No registration is required; the skill works with the data you supply without an account.

Filed alongside itours